Crumbl Review: Week 10/3 – 10/8


Erica Ellison, Staff Writer

This week at Crumbl Cookies, we had an interesting line up of cookies including Caramel Apple, Pumpkin Roll, Aggie Blue Mint, and Original Featuring Peanut Butter M&M’s. Not the most exciting flavors to here about but I still gave them a try.

Starting off with my favorite, Caramel Apple. This cookie had a base flavor of apple cinnamon but it was not too strong of a flavor. The light cookie flavor left room for the icing to come out. The icing was a caramel cream cheese frosting and it was my favorite part. I am usually not an icing person but this was perfect and not too sweet. The cookie was topped off with caramel drizzle and fresh apples which brought a good sour flavor to the cookie pallet. This cookie was not dry in the slightest and gets the rating of a 9/10.

The next cookie in the line up was Pumpkin Roll. Just based off how big and messy it looked at first, I didn’t have high hopes. I am usually not the biggest fan of pumpkin spice flavors but this cookie was not bad. I should also mention that it is not even a cookie. It has much more of a cake texture. The pumpkin spice flavor was not too overbearing and the cinnamon roll icing on top added the perfect amount of sweetness to the cookie. This cookie is not my favorite this week but does remind me a lot of fall. I would give this “cookie” a 7/10.

The third cookie this week was Original Featuring Peanut Butter M&M’s. I have never been a big peanut butter lover but this cookie was not bad. I will say however, that I could’ve gone without the peanut butter filled because it took away from the chocolate in the M&M’s. I feel like a chocolate cookie as the base would make this cookie 10 times better because it does lack other flavors other than peanut butter. I rate this cookie a 6/10

Last and certainly least, Aggie Blue Mint. Let me just start off by saying, I am not a mint person other than gum and this cookie did not change that fact. The flavor combination of mint and chocolate has always been gross to me. It was almost as if the icing was just toothpaste with oreo crumbs mixed in. The Oreo cookie base was fine but they could’ve left it at that with an Oreo icing. I’m sure mint lovers would enjoy this cookie but it was not for me. I give this cookie a 3/10.

Overall, this week was not worth it. Stay tuned for better upcoming Crumbl weeks that will hopefully be in my favor.